
Summary: This is a guide to help people understand what they're seeing when they see "martial arts".
Performance martial arts, or martial arts for show, is a classification of martial arts often seen, but rarely discussed. While it can be coupled with competitive martial arts, it is an entirely separate class since there is no fighting involved.
In some cases it has little or no martial application. Some of it does, some of it doesn't. Just always keep in mind that it is largely designed for show, not for practical application.
Honestly, there isn't a ton of well-put-together information about this - that's why I'm writing this. Some of it is done for testing purposes, some for demonstration, some for visual effect, some for all of the above.
Some things that fall into this category:
- Stage combat
- Breaking
- Tricking
- 'Extreme martial arts'
- Most film and television
I want to focus on 'martial arts' that are purely done for show. This is what you will see in most movies and on stage. The kind that you would see on America's Got Talent. This is what many people see and exemplify as martial arts. Most of this comes from a combination of gymnastics, dance, tricking, parkour and things of that nature in combination with elements that seem like martial arts. It is usually very physically and visually impressive. Most of the time it has little to no practical application.
So if you ever meet a 'martial artist' whose focus is this sort of stuff, keep in mind that their skills probably have little to do with the goals of fighting. That's not to say that they can't know about real martial applications - they might, but just be aware. Most people who see someone do a flip or something fancy think "oh geez that guy could kick anyones ass". Don't be fooled. It's a trap.
Also note that people are given black belts for performance-based styles. Yet another example of how meaningless a black belt really is.
Keep in mind that I'm not saying performance martial arts isn't a legitimate field.. after all, I work in it doing fight choreography and stunts. There's certainly a place for it. Just remember though, it's just like everything else you see on film and TV - it's not real. It's done for entertainment, for art and for fun.


8 comments:
That's an awesome photo.
Very true, Jesse. I don't have anything against these performance arts. In fact, they are great fitness and very interesting to watch. But, they are (I think) more akin to the dancing arts than martial arts. But, if competition skill or performance ability is someone's goal...then there is a place for them to persue it. As long as, like you said, they know it going in.
Here is another one I liked from a spectator point of view...
Competition...Keeps Things Interesting
There is nothing wrong with performance art. It is fun to watch and general serves for a nice break in the action. I do agree with you though that getting black belts for performance arts is a little like giving a gymnast a belt belt. Sure both are great atheletes, but no one is going to get the snot beaten out of them 2 and 1/2 twisting somersault! Did I spell that right?? LOL
@marc @anonymous -
Definitely agree, I don't have anything against it - after all, it's what I do.
And a note on practicality - many times I have found performance martial arts to be more applicable than some supposed "martial" martial arts that are actually being trained for fighting or self defense purposes.
@Cherdon - the flipping guy or admiral ackbar?
Wow...you are really on the borderline of this one: is it or is it not a martial art, this extreme performance based stuff. Or...let's be frank, is it bullsh** or not?
I've been in the martial arts game off and on for many years and my participation and interest in it has always been self-defense. The simpler and more practical, the better. This is why I am involved in the FMA and part of the reason why I view your brilliant blog every week. This ninja turtle stuff looks fantastic and requires tremendous acrobatic training in order to pull off. I envy these people for their physical conditioning but as you know, it takes very little physical ability to defend yourself in a pinch. A little bit of self-defense and common sense is all you need to stay alive.
I get a kick out of watching those Paul Mitchell team demos on cable TV: aerobicise karate and fat guys who break cinder blocks. Whole lotta fun to watch but I can't help but think if the aerobicisers have practical weapon defense skills (non-ballistic of course) or even if they can take a shot to the jaw. Although, I must admit, I wouldn't want to mess with the cinder block guys in a dark alley, or anywhere for that matter -- they're brutes.
Keep up the good work and your frankness is refreshing to read.
Happy holidays.
Is this what you mean by Performance Martial Arts?
Tricking in NYC
Scene from "Never Back Down"
Even 'traditional martial arts' can be broken up into further classifications, such as traditional vs classical, and self defense vs life protection.
Lots of variety out there, that's for sure.
Post a Comment
- Your email address will not be displayed.
- You can use some HTML tags, such as <b>, <i>, <a>.
- URLs will not auto-link. Use the following HTML to post links: <a href="http://yoururl.com">name of the page</a>